题库> 逻辑 CR> CR-e7gdpk

题目选项分析

Public health expert: Increasing the urgency of a public health message may be counterproductive. In addition to irritating the majority who already behave responsibly, it may undermine all government pronouncements on health by convincing people that such messages are overly cautious. And there is no reason to believe that those who ignore measured voices will listen to shouting.

The two sections in boldface play which of the following roles in the public health expert's argument?

【选项】The first is the argument's main conclusion; the second supports that conclusion and is itself a conclusion for which support is provided.

选项是否正确?

答对用户笔记

学员sWV85G
0人
学员sWV85G 2023-11-10 17:41:01
后半句说是conclusion是不太合适的
GMAT对于conclusion premise evidence 之类的有比较严格的区分,是premise就不会是conclusion
conyzhu
0人
conyzhu 2019-09-25 16:06:56
in addition to 前半句和后半句对象不同,关系并列属于论证,不是结论
premise的官方解释是“Premise: a fact, proposition, or statement from which a conclusion is made
dbextra
0人
dbextra 2018-10-09 16:37:15
这道题错选了C选项,主要是觉得E选项的premise不对,但考友给出了premise的官方解释是“Premise: a fact, proposition, or statement from which a conclusion is made.”,所以可以知道对于第二句作用的解释显然是E选项比C更为准确,C选项说其本身也是一个结论,是不太合适的,这是一个事实evidence或者fact,而并非是一个结论。
livingston666
0人
livingston666 2018-08-22 15:51:22
第二句并不是结论
YJoanna
0人
YJoanna 2018-05-22 17:59:19
in addition to 前半句和后半句对象不同,关系并列属于论证,不是结论
GabriellaLi
0人
GabriellaLi 2018-03-05 21:40:13
he first is the argument’s main conclusion; the second supports that conclusion 正确,本身并不是被支持的结论
lurenjiazi
0人
lurenjiazi 2017-11-30 15:27:11
错在for which support is provided
第二句确实是个论据,且本身为观点,但没有进一步支持它本身的观点
飘fly
0人
飘fly 2017-11-28 16:49:05
第二个BF没有support,and后面的内容是support main conclusion即第一条BF的原因
richivalryard
0人
richivalryard 2017-10-09 04:53:35
此题比较好做。第一个黑体部分:公共健康信息的与日增加的紧迫性是达不到目标的。(显然是结论,排除ABD)后面是论证结论的论点——不仅会惹恼原来...,而且也会削弱政府对于健康方面的公示效果,因为人们被确信这些信息太‘杞人忧天’了。(论点之一,自身并非结论,排除C)

题目基本信息

  • 所属科目:逻辑CR
  • 题目来源1:OG16-81
  • 题目来源2:OG17-624
  • 题目来源3:OG18-623
  • 题目来源4:OG19-623
  • 题目来源5:OG20-714
  • 题目来源6:OG2022-768
难度:难
Get Microsoft Silverlight
Get Microsoft Silverlight